McKinley, Robin. Rose Daughter. Greenwillow Books, 1997.
Reason read: August is supposed to be Fairytale month.
Everyone knows the story of Beauty and the Beast. What makes McKinley’s Rose Daughter different is the treatment of Beast. Yes, the moral of the story still stands that true love is blind and even a beast can find love…eventually. Yes, Beauty is selfless and kind, a lover of all nature (even bats and toads), but missing is the feeling she is a prisoner; that she is trapped with the beast. In Rose Daughter she can go home at any time. All she has to do is tend to the Beast’s roses to repay him for the dark red one her father stole. The other major difference is that Beauty does not end up with a charming prince at the end. I greatly appreciated the choices she had to make, especially the one at the end.
As an aside: Straight away you know you are in for a treat when a bad-tempered dragon on a leash is introduced on the very first page.
Everyone has a goofy name: Lionheart, Jeweltongue, Horsewise, Longchance, Treeworthy, Bestcloth,
Spoiler alert: Beauty puts the second rose petal on her tongue to get back to Beast. She is frantic because she has finally figured out that she loves him and if she doesn’t return to him in time he will die. She is in this mad rush to tell him, yes! Yes, she will marry him. In her confusion upon reentry to his world, she finds an old lady who takes several pages (and ages) to explain the curse put upon Beast. I know it is a tactic to bring the reader up to speed (Beauty couldn’t have known anything of this beforehand or else she wouldn’t have fallen in love with him properly), but the sense of urgency is lost and that suspense of “will she get back to Beast in time to save his life” is gone.
Author fact: I am reading four of McKinley’s novels for the Challenge. Spindle’s End and The Outlaws of Sherwood are the last two titles on my McKinley list.
Book trivia: Rose Daughter is McKinley’s second retelling of Beauty and the Beast.
Nancy said: Pearl said that Rose Daughter is a good choice for teenage girls.
BookLust Twist: from More Book Lust in the chapter called “Fractured Fairytales” (p 93).
~*LunaSea*~ 