Invisible People
Posted: 2021/03/14 Filed under: Book Reviews, Fiction, Graphic Novel, Lust To Go | Tags: 2021, april, book lust iii, book review, Fiction, graphic novel, new york, Will Eisner Leave a commentEisner, Will. Will Eisner’s New York: the Big City: Invisible People. New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 1992.
Reason read: to finish the series started in January.
The stories in Will Eisner’s New York: the Big City keep getting sadder and sadder. The subtle humor once found in earlier stories has slipped away in Invisible People. Take Pincus Pleatnik from the short story “Sanctum.” Someone at the newspaper has made a mistake and prematurely put his name in the obituary section. Because Pincus is an unmemorable (invisible) man no one believes him when he tries to prove his living-and-breathing existence. Then there is the librarian, a spinster in her 40s in “Mortal Combat.” She spent her entire life looking after her father. Despite the many sacrifices she has made over the years to care for her dad, once he passes she believes it is not too late to have a life of her own. She tries…except she choses a man exactly like herself, locked into a lifetime of caring for a parent.
As an aside, I was reminded of the lyrics from “Motherland”, a Natalie Merchant song: “Nameless, faceless, innocent, blameless, free. Now tell me what that’s like to be.” The people in Invisible People are indeed nameless and faceless.
Only quote I liked, “the pity of it is that deep-city dwellers carefully sidestep the human debris that they see in the doorways and crannies around them” (p 41).
Author fact: Eisner said he wrote Invisible People in anger. He read an article about a woman who was failed by the system. You can read more about it here.
Book trivia: Invisible People is the last set of stories in Will Eisner’s New York.
Nancy said: Pearl said Invisible People as one of the books about New York City she really liked.
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust To Go in the chapter called “New York: a Taste of the Big Apple” (p 151).
City People Notebook
Posted: 2021/02/26 Filed under: Book Reviews, Fiction, Graphic Novel, Lust To Go | Tags: 2021, book lust iii, book review, Fiction, graphic novel, march, new york, NonFiction, Will Eisner Leave a commentEisner, Will. Will Eisner’s New York: Life in the Big City: City People Notebook. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1989.
Reason read: to continue the series started in January.
I am starting to notice a pattern with Eisner’s work: there is a level of subtle tragedy in every story in Will Eisner’s New York. One example – in City People Notebook the throngs of people moving down the bustling sidewalk do not give notice to the man in terrible distress, apparently having a heart attack until he lies prostrate on the sidewalk, dead. It’s a terrible image.
Despite the sadness there is some humor (Hotel LaSleaze where a man assumes he has anonymity and takes out an escort). I especially liked the smell shock. The city smells so bad you don’t recognize when it is on fire.
The same street has many different personalities: empty, angry, sad. Eisner studies the relationship between people and these streets. He calls it an “archaeological study of city people.” The lonely people, the suspicious people, the harried people. They all flow through the streets on their way somewhere. All the while they are unaware of the environmental factors of time, smell, rhythm and space. There is a certain cadence to the city – the element of speed through a maze; a certain cacophony of emissions.
Author fact: Eisner died in January 2005.
Book trivia: Eisner offers up a new introduction for City People Notebook in his compendium.
Nancy said: Pearl lists City People Notebook as one of the books about New York City she really liked.
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust To Go in the chapter called “New York City: a Taste of the Big Apple” (p 151).
The Building
Posted: 2021/02/15 Filed under: Book Reviews, Fiction, Graphic Novel, Lust To Go | Tags: 2021, book lust iii, book review, february, Fiction, graphic novel, new york, NonFiction, Will Eisner Leave a commentEisner, Will. Will Eisner’s New York: Life in the Big City: The Building. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1987.
Reason read: to continue the series started in January.
So much tragedy and human heartache surrounding one building: the story of Monroe, a man trying to save all the children of New York after an accident involving a young boy changes his entire life; PJ Hammond and his singular obsession to buy the building he grew up in; the love affair between Gilda and poor poet, Benny in the shadow of the building (until Gilda goes and marries someone else for money); and Antonio Tonatti, the man who loved to play music in front of the majestic building until it was torn down. One building, so many stories. It’s as if the giant structure made of glass and steel stood guard over all these lives.There is one final story which ties all the other stories together. It’s bittersweet and beautiful. Quintessential New York.
Author fact: Eisner has a comic Hall of Fame award named after him.
Book trivia: Look carefully at the illustrations. Characters come back from other stories.
Nancy said: The Building is included in a list of books about New York that Pearl has enjoyed.
BookLust Twist: From Book Lust To Go in the chapter called “New York City: A Taste of the Big Apple” (p 151).
Will Eisner’s New York: the Big City: New York
Posted: 2021/02/02 Filed under: Book Reviews, BookLust I, E-Books, Graphic Novel, NonFiction | Tags: 2021, book lust i, book review, february, Fiction, graphic novel, new york, NonFiction, Will Eisner Leave a commentEisner, Will. Will Eisner’s New York: the Big City: New York. New York: D.C. Comics, 1981.
Reason read: Will Eisner passed away in the month of January. Read in his memory.
Every time I think of New York I cannot help but also think of Natalie Merchant’s song, “Carnival.” How could I not? It’s an homage to a great city of contradiction. Her line, “A wild-eyed mystic prophet, on a traffic island, stopped and he raved of saving me” evokes so many conflicting emotions. Thanks to my nephew being born in New York City, I got to waken a dormant love for the Big Apple. Sights, smells, and sounds that are often times distasteful to some (like my husband), fill me with inexplicable energy and ambition. I want to run Central Park like I live on the upper west side. It’s as if New York’s grit and grime are tangible forms of strength and tenacity that speak loudly to me. In New York, Will Eisner captures perfectly the stark reality of the big city’s silent and subtle struggles. You can smell the stench of all corners of New York, hear the frenetic activity in every sentence. But, look and look again very carefully. There is power in what isn’t said. Look at the illustration of the people riding the subway. You can almost hear the rattle of the rails; and when the train grinds to a halt during a blackout there’s that one guy who doesn’t change expression. As the minutes tick by, the people around him slowly start to panic while he stoically stares ahead. There truly is always that one guy and if you were on that train, you would see him. This is a portrait of an important city doing unimportant things, all lovingly expressed in a series of vignettes; the constants of New York: Avenue C which connect the East side to West, the importance of stoops, the sentinels of the City (hydrants, mailboxes, traffic signals, lampposts, windows, and sewers), and the people. You can read the entire thing in minutes, but that only means you have time to read it again and again and again.
Best quotes, “The big city is after all a hive of concrete and steel in which living things swarm. Depositing, in the course of their lives, the residue of their existence, in the countless garbage cans that sit dumbly amid the swirl” (p 41).
Author fact: Will Eisner popularized the term “graphic novel.”
Book trivia: After New York the tribute to New York continues with The Building, City People Notebook, and, Invisible People.
Nancy said: Pearl said she really enjoyed New York.
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust in the chapter called “New York City: A Taste of the Big Apple” (p 151).
Ethel and Ernest
Posted: 2019/05/14 Filed under: Book Reviews, BookLust I, Graphic Novel, NonFiction | Tags: 2019, biography, book lust i, book review, childhood, graphic novel, may, NonFiction, Raymond Briggs Leave a commentBriggs, Raymond. Ethel and Ernest: a True Story. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1999.
Reason read: May is Graphic Novel month. I read that somewhere.
This is Raymond Brigg’s story of his parents as a couple from the moment they met until death did them part. Simplistic in graphic novel form but powerful in message. What started off as an accidental communication for the couple kicked off a poignant romance that lasted fifty years. Brigg’s loving tribute continues through his parents’s courtship and marriage, his mom giving birth to him at 38 years old (their only child), the war and the political aftermath, the ravages of aging, and finally each of their deaths. What makes the retelling so heartwarming is Brigg’s ability to communicate parental emotion. Every fear, hope, happiness and expectation they felt towards their son was delivered and exposed in loving detail.
Author fact: Briggs was removed from his parents (evacuated during the war for safety) when he was five years old.
Book trivia: Ethel and Ernest is a graphic novel.
Nancy said: Pearl called Ethel and Ernest a “touching story” (Book Lust p 103).
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust in the chapter called “Graphic Novels” (p 103). Interestingly enough, the title Ethel and Ernest and author Raymond Briggs are missing from the index.
Alice in Sunderland
Posted: 2016/04/15 Filed under: Book Reviews, Fiction, Graphic Novel, Lust To Go, NonFiction | Tags: 2016, april, book lust iii, book review, Bryan Talbot, Fiction, graphic novel, Lewis Carroll, NonFiction Leave a commentTalbot, Bryan. Alice in Sunderland. Milwaukie, OR: Dark Horse Books, 2007
Reason read: April Fools
One word: savor. Savor this book slowly. It’s only 319 pages but let every page have it’s moment in time. This is a beautiful piece of art, chock full of culture, biography, history, creative use of the English language (“follow your spirit” with a picture of someone chasing a vodka truck), a comic book inside a graphic novel, brimming with literary references (Thirty-Nine Steps and Rugby, the same school made infamous by Tom Brown’s Schooldays, to name a few) and much, much more. This is a comprehensive walk through history with a myriad of people and places leading the way. In Book Lust To Go Nancy Pearl called it “one of the richest experiences of her life (p 68).
The premise is really quite simple. Bryan Talbot has researched his hometown of Sunderland and found every possible parallel connection to Lewis Carroll’s famed The Adventures of Alice in Wonderland. It’s brilliant. Read this alongside The Annotated Alice for a healthy dose of all things Wonderland.
Best quote, “All the lives seen tonight…so many lives…” (p 290). Case in point: here’s the ridiculously long list of Who’s Who in Alice in Sunderland. How about a game? How many people do you recognize?:
- Abraham Lincoln
- Al Davison
- Alan Hargreaves
- Alexandria “Xie” Kitchin
- Alfred Jarry
- Alice Liddell
- Ally Sloper
- Andy Capp
- Arthur Racham
- Arthur Frost
- Bande Dessinee
- Beatles
- Bede
- Benedict Biscop
- Benny Hill
- Beryl Formby
- Bessie Wilcox
- Betty Boop
- Bill Shakespeare
- Blondin
- Bobby Thompson
- Bram Stoker
- Bryan Ferry
- Caedmon
- Capt. Edward Robinson
- Capt. Joseph Wiggins
- Capt. William Bligh
- Caryl Hargreaves
- Cary Grant
- Catherine Cookson
- Charles Dickens
- Charles Kingsley
- Charles Lutwidge Dodson
- Charles Weiss
- Charlie Chaplin
- Chaz Brenchley
- Chster P Hackenbush
- Chico Marx
- Chris Mullin
- Clarkson Stanfield
- Colin Wilbourn
- Craig Knowles
- Dante Gabriel Rossetti
- Dave Stewart
- David Malan
- David McKean
- Dennis Potter
- Dick Turpin
- Disraeli
- Doctor Who
- Dorothy Williamson
- Dracula
- Duke of Wellington
- Earl Zetland
- Earl of Bute
- Edgar Allan Poe
- Edgar Atheling
- Edith Liddell
- Edward Bulwer Lytton
- Edward Burne Jones
- Edward Hylton
- Edward Schoeder
- Edwin Moss
- Eileen O’Shaughnessy
- Elizabeth I
- Elizabeth Liddell
- Ellen Terry
- Emily Pankhurs
- Emperor Claudius
- Eric Gill
- Florence Becker Lennon
- Frank Caws
- Franz Kafka
- Frederick Cotton
- Fredericka Liddell
- Friar Tuck
- George “Dubya” Bush
- George Formby
- George Hudson
- George Lightfoot
- George Lilburne
- George Orwell
- George Stephenson
- George Washington
- Gerald Frow
- Gertrude Bell
- Grace Slick
- Grant Morrison
- Harry Furniss
- Harry Lauder
- Harry Potter
- Henry VIII
- Hedworth Williams, Sr.
- Henry George Liddell
- Henry Holiday
- Henry Hylton
- Henry Irving
- Henry Lambton
- Henry Stanley
- Houdini
- Hunt Emerson
- Ian Watson
- Irving Berlin
- Isabella Hazard
- Isambard Kingdom Brunel
- Jack Crawford
- Jack the Ripper
- James Herriot
- James Joyce
- Jan Svankmeyers
- Jeff Smith
- Jimmy Carter
- Joe Nattras
- John Bunyan
- John George Lambton
- John Humble
- John Lawrence
- John Lennon
- John Lilburne
- John Millais
- John Paul Jones
- John Proctor
- John Ruskin
- John Tenniel
- Jonathan Hanker
- Jonathan Miller
- Jordan Smith
- Joseph Conrad
- Joseph Swan
- Joseph Wiggins
- Joshua Wilson
- Karl Fisher
- Karl Marx
- Kate Adie
- Keanu Reeves
- Kelly Osbourne
- Ken Russell
- Kevin Cadwallender
- King Athelstan
- King Charles I
- King Ecgfrith
- King George I
- King Harold
- King James I
- Lady Montagu Wortley
- Lawrence of Arabia
- Leo Baxendale
- Leopold Hargreaves
- Les Dawson
- Lewis Carroll
- Lily Lumley
- Lizzie Webster
- Lord Ravensworth
- Luther Arkwright
- MacDonald Gill
- Manfred Mann
- Manuella Bute Smedley
- Margaret Thatcher
- Marie Lloyd
- Marilyn Manson
- Marilyn Monroe
- Mark Lemon
- Marlene Dietrich
- Mary Ann Robson Cotton
- Mary Shelley
- Mary Wortley
- Max Ernst
- Mervyn Peake
- Michael Bute
- Michelangelo
- Mike D’Abo
- Miles Standish
- Mother Shipton
- Mr T
- Nannie Scott
- Ned Kelly
- Neil Gaiman
- Nellie Melba
- Nicholas Hawksmoor
- Odo of Bayeux
- Olga Lowe
- Olive Hardy
- Oliver Goldsmith
- Oswald Moseley
- Oswald Stoll
- Ozzy Osbourne
- Patrick Lavelle
- Paul McCartney
- Peter Camm
- Peter O’Toole
- Peter Smart
- Peter Sutcliffe
- Prince Leopold
- Queen Elizabeth II
- Queen Victoria
- Ralph Steadman
- Ravi Shankar
- Reginald Hargreaves
- Rev. Charles Collingwood
- Rev. John Wesley
- Rev. Robert Gray
- Rex Hargreaves
- Rhoda Liddell
- Richard Nixon
- Richard Thornton
- Richard Wallace
- Rick Griffin
- Robert Bowes
- Robert Graves
- Robert Heinlein
- Robert Liltburne
- Robert Stephenson
- Robin Hood
- Robinson Duckworth
- Roger Skelton
- Roland Wilson
- Rudolf Toffer
- Saint Cuthbert
- Saint Godric
- Saint Hilda
- Sally Geeson
- Salvador Dali
- Samuel Taylor Coleridge
- Sarah Junner Lawrence
- Sarah Michelle Gellar
- Scott McCloud
- Septimus Scott
- Sheri Holman
- Sidney James
- Sir Henry Havelock
- Sir Humphrey Davy
- Sir John Lambton
- Sir John Conyers
- Sir Walter Scott
- Sir William of Hylton
- Stan Laurel
- Steven Spielberg
- Stuart Dodgson Collingwood
- Suzy Varty
- T Arthur
- TS Eliot
- Tennyson
- Thomas Dixon
- Thomas Edison
- Thomas Edward Lawrence
- Thomas Henry Liddell
- Thomas Paine
- Thomas Randall
- Tom Taylor
- Tony Blair
- Tove Jansson
- Trina Robbins
- Ulysses S Grant
- Vesta Tilley
- Virginia Woolf
- Vladimir Nabokov
- WC Fields
- WH Auden
- Wee Georgie Woods
- Whoopi Goldberg
- Wilkie Collins
- William Bell Scott
- William Blake
- William Clanny
- William Hogarth
- William Hylton
- William Joyce
- William McGonagall
- William Mills
- William Morris
- William Mowbray
- William Reid Clanny
- William the Bastard
- William the Conqueror
- William Wilcox
- Windson McKay
- Winnie Davies
- Woody Allen
- Yehudi Menhin
Fun stuff: Ever wonder why all public doors are supposed to open outward? The answer is in Alice in Sunderland. Did you know there is a missing Alice chapter called Wasp in a Wig? Or that Grace Slick is such a huge fan of Alice that she created a whole series of Wonderland inspired paintings when she retired from music.
Favorite line, “Don’t confuse the genre with the medium” (p 187).
Author fact: Talbot has his own website here.
Book trivia: I know I said it before but this book is an oversized visual treat.
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust To Go in the chapter called “Comics with a Sense of Place” (p 68).
A.D.
Posted: 2016/02/01 Filed under: Book Reviews, Graphic Novel, Lust To Go, NonFiction | Tags: 2016, book lust iii, book review, graphic novel, january, Josh Neufeld, new orleans, NonFiction 4 CommentsNeufeld, Josh. A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge. New York: Pantheon Books, 2010.
Reason read: Mardi Gras is held in New Orleans every February. Rather than read this in August (typical because of the date of Hurricane Katrina) I decided to twist it up a little. Just as Pearl did (see BookLust Twist at the end of this review).
Right from the very beginning you know you are in for something deeply moving and very special when reading the graphic novel A.D. (although technically it is not a novel. Novel implies fiction, right?). Neufeld starts the reader off looking at Earth from outer space. As we look down on North America we almost get a sense of the calm before the storm. On the next page the graphic orientates us to the tragedy to come as we get a bird’s eye view of the city of New Orleans. We are coming in closer. We see the city as one entity and the storm as another, as if they are two strangers being introduced at a party. As the days go by we follow the lives of seven New Orleans residents. This becomes a biography of each individual.
To me, what is incredibly sad is the emphasis on their naivete, their attitude of “this is no big deal” all because hurricanes in their corner of the world come and go. They have lived through them before. They are experts in the realm of weather. That may be true, but no one expected the levies to go…
Yes. You can read this in one day as posting this on the first implies. My recommendation? Read it several times. Read and share it. There is a message hidden in the comic.
My favorite StopYouInYourTracks quote: “At least then we wouldn’t have had to walk on top of the things I cared about the most” (Leo, on page 171).
As an aside: Neufeld wasn’t the only artist to be shocked by Hurricane Katrina. Many talented individuals expressed their grief through art. But, listen to Natalie Merchant. She wrote a song called “Go Down Moses” (on her self titled album) that addresses not only the city of New Orleans after the hurricane, but the Danziger Bridge tragedy as well. Danziger is what she was referring to when she says, “let your people cross over.” Sad.
Author fact: the author of A.D. is JOSH Neufeld. Josh, not Joshua as Nancy Pearl refers to him. He is Josh in twelve different places in the book: on the front cover, on the title page, four times on the copyright page, in the afterward, on the “about the author” page, on the back flap and three in separate instances on the back cover. Not once does the name “Joshua” appear anywhere. Call me crazy, but I think he wants to be called Josh. For more information on Josh and this project, check out this link.
Book trivia: this was a New York Times best seller. Of course it was.
BookLust Twist: in Book Lust To Go but not for the reasons you would think. You’re thinking this would be in the chapter “New Orleans” but it’s not. It’s in “Comics with a Sense of Place” (p 68).
Changing It Up January
Posted: 2014/12/31 Filed under: audio book, Early Review, Fiction, Graphic Novel, NonFiction, Poetry | Tags: adventure, Baltimore, fantasy, Fiction, graphic novel, mystery, nature, new jersey, NonFiction, Poetry, postmodern, russia, world war ii Leave a commentA new year deserves new things; new ways of thinking and new ways of doing. Here is the list I promised in December. Instead of separating the list into “finished” and “still to go”, I thought for this go-round I would just cross off the titles I finished. This system will force me to stay on top of the books I add, but we’ll see…Just testing something…
As an aside, I gave up completely on Robert Jordan. Sorry.
Dragon Reborn by Robert Jordan(DNF)In a Strange City by Laura Lippman- By a Spider’s Thread by Laura Lippman (AB)
Recognitions by William Gaddis(DNF)Maus by Art SpiegelmanLady Franklin’s Revenge by Ken McGooganBrief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao* by Junot Diaz (AB)
Walk in the Woods by Bill BrysonEugene Onegin by Alexander PushkinShadow Rising by Robert JordanADDED: A Good Doctor’s Son by Steven SchwartzADDED: Drinking: a Love Story by Caroline KnappADDED: Ancient Rome on 5 Denarii a Day by Philip MatyszakADDED: Nero Wolfe Cookbook by Rex StoutADDED: Treasure Hunter by W. Jameson (ER)- Maus II by Art Spiegelman (Jan)
- Wild Blue by Stephen Ambrose (Jan)
- Shot in the Heart by Mikal Gilmore (Jan)
- Greater Nowheres by David Finkelstein/Jack London (Jan)
- ADDED: Alma Mater by P.F Kluge (Jan)
- Good Life by Ben Bradlee (Feb)
- Underworld by Don DeLillo (Feb)
- Her Name Was Lola by Russell Hoban (Feb)
- Man Who Was Thursday by GK Chesterton ((Feb)
Fires From Heaven by Robert Jordan(Feb)- Finnegan’s Wake by James Joyce (Feb)
- At Home with the Glynns by Eric Kraft (Feb)
- Polish Officer by Alan Furst (Feb)
Lord of Chaos by Robert Jordan(Mar)- Chasing Monarchs by Robert Pyle (Mar)
- Murder on a Kibbutz by Batya Gur (Mar)
- Bebe’s By Golly Wow by Yolanda Joe (Mar)
- Lives of the Muse by Francine Prose (Mar)
- Broom of the System (David Wallace (Mar)
Crown of Swords by Robert Jordan(Apr)- Two Gardeners by Emily Wilson (Apr)
- Royal Flash by George Fraser (Apr)
- Fifties by David Halberstam (Apr)
- Binding Spell by Elizabeth Arthur (Apr)
Crown of Swords by Robert Jordan(Apr)Path of Daggers by Robert Jordan(May)- Flash for Freedom! by George Fraser (May)
- Murder in Amsterdam by Ian Buruma (May)
- Petra: lost city by Christian Auge (May)
- From Beirut to Jerusalem by Thomas Friedman (May)
- Jordan by E. Borgia (May)
- Coroner’s Lunch by Colin Cotterill (May)
- Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese (May)
- Flash at the Charge by George MacDonald Fraser (May)
- Castles in the Air by Judt Corbett (Jun)
- Battle Cry of Freedom by James McPherson (Jun)
- Thirty-three Teeth by Colin Cotterill (Jun)
- Millstone by Margaret Drabble (Jun)
Winter’s Heart by Robert Jordan(Jun)Crossroads of Twilight by Robert Jordan(Jul)- Disco for the Departed by Colin Cotterill (Jul)
- Sixty Stories by Donald Barthelme (Jul)
- New Physics and Cosmology by Arthur Zajonc (Jul)
- Grifters by Jim Thompson (Jul)
- Complete Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle (Jul)
- Snow Angels by James Thompson (Jul)
- Ararchy and Old Dogs by Colin Cotterill (Aug)
- Flashman’s Lady by George MacDonald Fraser (Aug)
- Possession by AS Byatt (Aug)
- In the Footsteps of Ghanghis Khan by John DeFrancis (Aug)
- What Just Happened by James Gleick (Aug)
- Game of Kings by Dorothy Dunnett (Aug)
- Curse of the Pogo Stick by Colin Cotterill (Sep)
- Flashman and the Redskins by George MacDonald Fraser (Sep)
- Queens’ Play by Dorothy Dunnett (Sep)
- Robber Bride by Margaret Atwood (Sep)
- Mysterious Affair at Styles by Agatha Christie (Sep)
- Beautiful Struggle by Ta-Nehisi Coates (Sep)
- Then She Found Me by Elinor Lipman (Oct)
- Merry Misogynist by Colin Cotterill (Oct)
- Disorderly Knights by Dorothy Dunnett (Oct)
- Flashman and the Dragon by George MacDonald Fraser (Oct)
- Dark Hills Divide by Patrick Carman (Nov)
- Love Songs from a Shallow Grave by Collin Cotterill (Nov)
- Flashman and the Mountain of Light by George MacDonald Fraser (Nov)
- Pawn in Frankincense by Dorothy Dunnett (Nov)
- Andorra by Peter Cameron (Nov)
DNF = Did Not Finish;AB = Audio Book; ER = Early Review
So, right off the bat I see something I don’t like. When I add new books they don’t get their “day in the sun” so to speak. I add them to the list and then cross them off immediately. That doesn’t seem fair.
Maus: a Survivor’s Tale
Posted: 2014/12/09 Filed under: Book Reviews, BookLust I, Graphic Novel, NonFiction | Tags: 2014, Art Spiegelman, biography, book lust i, book review, december, graphic novel, NonFiction, world war ii Leave a commentSpiegelman, Art: Maus I: A Survivor’s Tale. My Father Bleeds History. New York: Pantheon Books, 1973.
Maus I is such a curious conundrum. On the one hand, you are mostly looking at pictures. The very idea of a “comic book” is something out of childhood and inherently considered “light reading.” Definitely not something to be taken seriously. On the other hand, you have Spiegelman’s story itself: a son interviewing his father to get the perspective of a Polish Jew who survived the Nazi concentration camps of World War II. Fear, starvation, distrust, torture, suicide, execution, genocide. All pretty heavy subject matter and without a doubt, difficult to read in any context. Even in his characterization Spiegelman plays with our perceptions. He uses enemies in the natural world to drive home the story; using cats for the Germans and mice for the Jews; pigs for the police.
Here’s the underlying truth, the war never leaves Spiegelman’s father. Even though he survived the war, survived the concentration camps, survived to tell his tale, he lives in the shadow of memory. He worries constantly about money; is distrustful of his own family’s intentions (trying to steal from him). Betrayals of the past run deep and dictate how he trusts others.
Reason read: Pearl Harbor anniversary is Dec 7th (Remembrance Day). Confessional: I started this in November in honor of Veterans’ Day.
Stop and think line, “He survived me my life that time” (p 80). Even though we would normally say, “he saved my life” I think this phrasing, saying the word “survived” carries more weight.
Author fact: Check out the author info in Maus I. There is a lot going on in the illustration.
Book trivia: My favorite part was the comic within the graphic novel. The styles were so vastly different. The importance of the comic was clearly illustrated.
BookLust Twist: from Book Lust in the chapter “Graphic Novels” (p 103).
